Stop trying to make television – it’s video

February 16, 2007

The online video bandwagon rolls on, with Media Week reporting that the Telegraph is to team up with ITN  for the “supply of broadcast content” (note the word ‘broadcast’). Meanwhile, today’s Press Gazette reports on the launch of new TV studios at VNU, and the Exeter’s Express & Star.

In all cases publishers seem to be making television – not video. A good example is the Telegraph’s video on London Fashion Week (WMV). It starts well – lots of footage of catwalk action: the sort of thing you can’t get across in print. But it then falls into standard TV package fare – headshot interviews with designers which could be much better placed in print where the reader can scan-read.

My suggestion: either drop the headshots and run the interviews over catwalk shots; or combine video footage with a text report.

A much better example – ‘Elephant Rampage’ (WMV). Quirky, compelling visuals, and a short piece which you could imagine on YouTube.

As for the Exeter Express & Star’s ‘Fire in Sowton’ piece, this begins with a TV news-style ‘presenter’ introducing the item before handing over to a reporter on the spot to deliver it. Why? On television, the presenter is there to anchor the whole and link different items, but online the webpage performs that function. This use of a presenter is not only wasting the viewer’s time, but the TV studio’s time. In fact, it begs the question, why do you need a TV studio at all? These publishers may come to realise they’ve wasted their money. 

Entry Filed under: magazines, online journalism, online video. .

3 Comments Add your own

  • 1. Newspaper video: It’s not TV. : Andy Dickinson.net  |  February 16, 2007 at 3:53 pm

    [...] Paul Bradshaw picks up on more interest around the whole newspaper video thing and, like many of us with an interest in the area, is would love newspapers maye think smarter about video and ’stop trying to make television’. [...]

    Reply
  • 2. Thinking outside the TV news box « reportr.net  |  February 20, 2007 at 5:38 pm

    [...] are rushing headlong into deals to offer video on their websites, but as Paul Bradshaw points out, “in all cases publishers seem to be making television – not [...]

    Reply
  • 3. More Gumbo  |  June 10, 2007 at 6:17 pm

    More Gumbo

    For the SECOND week in a row, I’m heading into town for a lunch meeting at Bayou City Seafood and Pasta. This time, I’m working with two guys who developed the best stock trading course I’ve ever seen.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Required

Required, hidden

Some HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


Feeds

Recent Comments

Walte Call on A model for the 21st century n…
A model for the 21st… on Wiki journalism: are wikis the…
naya thomas on Making a good magazine co…
Hicham Errachidi on Three ways of making a success…
tuppsypeelity on Some conflicting lessons on jo…

Top Posts

a

del.icio.us bookmarks

Blogroll

newspapers

Category Cloud

advertising blogs citizen journalism comments community computer aided reporting crowdsourcing databases enterprise facebook future journalism Guardian interactivity journalism magazines mobile phone news newspapers online audio online journalism online journalism careers online journalism education online journalism students online video RSS social networking twitter user generated content web 2.0 website relaunch wikis

Tags

5W+H 21st century newsroom amsterdam BASIC principles Bas Timmers Birmingham Post broadsheet delicious de Volkskrant emap facebook flickr gannett google Google Maps indie journalism integration iPM JEEcamp journalism mapping mashups Multimedia commission new media magazines Nicolas Kayser-Bril Nico Luchsinger online journalism atlas picnic07 Portugal press gazette privacy radio 4 RSS social bookmarking social media Something for the weekend tweetscan twitter UCLAN UGC United Kingdom vodcasts Wired Yahoo! Pipes youtube

Get OJB on your mobile

RSS Twitter feed